KHFMA Info

This post will serve as the all you need to know, one-stop-shop compilation of key information about the Kahekili Herbivore Fisheries Management Area (KHFMA), and associated education and outreach through the Division of Aquatic Resources (DAR) and the Ka'anapali Makai Watch program, coordinated jointly by DAR, the Coral Reef Alliance (CORAL), and Project S.E.A.-Link, with the support of many other groups and community members and volunteers.

Please visit the links below to learn more and access useful resources.

Information on KHFMA Boundaries, Rules and Regulations:

Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resources (DLNR) Division of Aquatic Resources' Regulated Fishing Areas in Maui County, KHFMA

Information about KHFMA and West Maui Priority Site:

Hawaii Coral Strategy West Maui Priority Site

Ka'anapali-Kahekili Watershed Management Plan

University of Hawai'i Kahekili Reef Recovery Site website

Facebook:

Kahekili Herbivore Fisheries Management Area Page

Ka'anapali Makai Watch Page

Other Resources:

Download the Making a Difference Action Guide - What to do and who to call concerning ocean issues in Hawaii

Reef Resilience Workshop for the Maui Nui Marine Resource Council

http://reefresilience.org/

 On April 28th & 29th, 2012, the Maui Nui Marine Resource Council (MNMRC; mnmrc.org) and associated Community Marine Management Area (CMMA) groups (Polanui and Kahului Harbor) participated in the Climate Change and Reef Resilience workshop hosted by Darla White of the Maui DLNR Division of Aquatic Resources, and Dr. Eric Conklin, Director of Marine Science for The Nature Conservancy of Hawai`i.  The event was held at the NOAA Humpback Whale National Marine Sanctuary in Kihei, with the field component hosted by Ekolu Lindsey at the Polanui CMMA.  To learn more about the purpose of the workshop, visit the previous blog at: http://mauioceanbloggers.blogspot.com/2011/12/reef-resilience-and-climate-change-in.html

If the perils of our time are unprecedented, then so are the opportunities.  – Anonymous

Climate Change and Reef Resilience Training held at the NOAA Humpback Whale
National Marine Sanctuary  in Kihei,  April 28th, 2012

Robin Knox reports out for her group's reef resilience mapping activity.

Takeo and Char report on their group's strategy to manage
coral reefs in the face of climate change.

Takeo (MNMRC) talks about the importance of fish nursery
areas and estuaries for sustaining fisheries into the future.

Back: John Seebart (Makai Watch), Itana Silva (DAR),
John Gorman (MOC & MNMRC), Takeo Miyaguchi
(MNMRC); Front: Larry Stevens (MNMRC)

Surfrider Foundation's Timothy Lara
and Hannah Bernard
report on managing for resilience.

Linda Castro, Maui Nui Marine Resource Council,
Polanui Community Marine Management Area (CMMA), &
DLNR Division of Aquatic Resources technician

Dr. Eric Conklin, Director of Marine Science
 for The Nature Conservancy of Hawai`i

This course can be taken online for a certificate in a self-paced format at https://www.conservationtraining.org

1) Create a profile

2) Go to the "Course Catalog" drop down list

 - select 'Waters', then select 'Oceans'

3) Scroll down to Reef Resilience Curriculum 1, 2, & 3.  (Principles of Reef Resilience, Resilient MPA Design and Managing for Reef Resilience) 

4) Select the desired curriculum and it will go to a new page.  On the left-hand bar you will see an option to 'enroll in the course'.  Select to enroll and off you go!

Participants learned about the threats of climate change on coral reef ecosystems, including warming waters, sea level rise, and ocean acidification.   But they also learned that there is hope for corals to survive and even thrive into the future.  Research from around the globe over the past decade has demonstrated that there are a number of factors that confer resilience that we can proactively manage for to keep our reefs healthy and give them the greatest advantage.   Additionally, adopting adaptive management practices  (i.e. the flexibility to make changes as necessary) is key to effective management in this changing climate. 

Participants took all of this new knowledge into the water to look at three reefs with new eyes.  This has been probably the most valuable part of the trainings thus far, as even participants that have been in the water their whole life found that they saw things in a new way, with a new understanding of the reefs and the complex sets of factors that influence reef health.  

The MNMRC and CMMA groups are the most important new managers for the future of Maui's reefs, as they are the communities that are so connected to these precious resources.  CMMAs are known throughout the Pacific as LMMAs (Locally Marine Managed Area; http://www.lmmanetwork.org/) and have been hugely successful in the management of reefs in other island nations.  Co-management of the resources here in Hawai`i is the future.  We all have to work together to keep our reefs healthy for future generations.    

The Reef Resilience workshop goes to the field: Kahekili Beach Park
From left to right: John Seebart, Robin Knox, Eric Conklin, Liz Bodanski, Itana Silva, John Gorman, Larry Stevens, Takeo Miyaguchi, Lisa Agdeppa, Jonathan Lindsey, Darla White, and Linda Castro.  (Ekolu Lindsey took the photo)
.

COMMIT CLEAN WATER ACTS!

submitted by Robin Knox, Water Quality Consulting, Inc.

Commit Clean Water Acts: Please send an email to the Department of Health asking for more time for public review of the Hawaii Water Quality Report

The State Department of Health has released the 2008/2010 State of Hawaii Water Quality Monitoring and Assessment Report. Download it here

This important report that sets water quality priorities for the state came out between Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays... The comment period closes today and many people may not be aware of it.

Please submit comments in writing by 12/13/2011 to:
CleanWaterBranch@doh.hawaii.gov
Alec Wong, Clean Water Branch, Department of Health
919 Ala Moana Blvd., Room 301
Honolulu, Hawaii 96814
 
Quick Summary
The State Department of Health has released their water quality assessment and impaired waters list for public review .The Clean Water Act requires that states monitor the quality of water in streams, lakes, wetlands, and oceans.  Every two years the Hawaii Department of Health is required to provide an assessment of whether or not water bodies are meeting water quality goals  and report to Congress the list of impaired waters that are not supporting legally protected uses due to water quality issues. If waters are impaired studies are required to establish the Total Maximum Daily Loads for the pollutants causing the loss of the use (such as fishing or swimming or growing coral reefs).

The Hawaii Department of Health failed to submit this report to Congress during 2008, so this is the first update since the 2006.  The report however does not consider any new monitoring locations since 2006, but instead updates the assessment using the data from January 2006 to December 2009. The state changed the water quality goal for recreational uses of water (swimming, surfing, snorkeling, diving etc.), increasing the allowable fecal indicator bacteria  concentration in the water. The geometric mean criterion is now 35 colonies/ 100 ml of water verses the former 7 colonies/ 100 ml. There appear to be 10 beaches that were taken off the impaired waters list due only to the change in criteria (as opposed to data showing water quality improvement).

For Maui the assessment delists (removes the recreational use impairment ) Kahului Harbor, Kalama Park, and Kalepolepo Beach Park. This means these areas will not have priority for funding actions to reduce bacteria and improve water quality. These are some of the most polluted areas on Maui where there are known sewage effluent plumes. DOH and Maui water quality specialist Robin Knox have found bacterial levels that are higher at these sites than at  most  other coastal recreational water sites. Robin says that the effluent plume areas test higher for many kinds of bacteria, including fecal indicator bacteria. The Department of Health allows the County of Maui to inject treated sewage effluent into the ground water that seeps into the ocean in these areas. Robin believes that the increased nutrients associated with the sewage serves as food for bacteria and algae. The increased algal and bacterial growth clouds the water , increasing turbidity and blocking the sunlight that would kill disease-causing bacteria. To make matters worse, although the sewage is partially treated, it is NOT treated to kill disease causing bacteria and viruses. So we are injecting human waste that has not been disinfected into an environment that supports the growth of elevated concentrations of microbes.  This seems like a big risk to take with people’s health and our economy, not to mention coral reef health. If the current decision-making rules take these sites off of the impaired waters list when we know there is a reasonable potential for a problem, then maybe we need some public review and discussion of the rules and the decisions. DOH needs to provide more information and a “layman friendly” explanation to the public, and then allow adequate opportunity for public discussion and comment.

UPDATE 12/29/11: Thanks to a lot of emails, the deadline to comment has been extended to January 31, 2012. 

Reef Resilience and Climate Change in Hawaii

by Darla White and Dr. Eric Conklin

Aloha Ocean Stewards!

The first step in creating positive change in our islands, to ensuring the health and longevity of our natural resources, is to understand what the issues are. After all, if you don't know about the problems, how can you care?  And isn't it nice when all of that scientific information is put into an easy to digest summary format?  The University of Hawaii Sea Grant Program has been doing just that for some time now with scientific progress in Hawaii. Dr. Chip Fletcher has this great (short) publication that summarizes what we currently know about the impacts of climate change today in Hawaii that I hope each and every person will read.

What is Reef Resilience?

We’re familiar with the downward spiral story: Coral reefs are in crisis across the globe. The pressures from overfishing, coastal development, and pollution have been taking their toll on these once-thriving hallmarks of biodiversity for years, and now global stressors such as climate change are contributing to devastating declines around the world.  Maui’s reefs are no exception, with a number of our reefs in serious decline.

The good news is that with a little bit of help, reefs can be remarkably resilient to all of these pressures, and an international community of the best minds in coral reef science and management has been working for the past decade to develop the best strategies to maintain or restore the resilience of coral reefs. 

Resilience is the ability of systems to absorb, resist or recover from disturbances or to adapt to change while continuing to maintain essential functions and processes.  In a nutshell, coral reef resilience is really talking about coral reef health.  A healthy reef “immune system” is the key to biological resilience and the ability to stay healthy despite all the pressures that reefs face. 

Dr. Eric Conklin (The Nature Conservancy) and I recently completed a six month course in which we learned the latest and greatest lessons gleaned from this international reef resilience community. The course culminated in a five-day workshop in Palau, where we saw firsthand how the implementation of these lessons across many Pacific islands has tangibly benefited the reef resources of these islands and the communities that rely on them. Some of the greatest strengths of this approach include a place-based ecosystem focus, adaptive management flexibility, and inherent community involvement. 

In order to preserve Maui’s coral reefs into the future, new management approaches are needed and the application of reef resilience principals and tools to Maui’s coral reefs can lead to healthier reefs that are better able to sustain themselves and our community.

This upcoming week Eric and I will be hosting a Reef Resilience training for the Maui DAR office, and if you would like to learn more, you can!!!  Below is the link to the online reef resilience online course.  Follow the directions and you will receive a certificate at completion.  They did a really nice job putting this together.  There is a veritable plethora of new information and resources here that are of great value...because we never stop learning. 

Reef Resilience Online Training

I hope that you will take the time to explore this website with your morning coffee.  Enjoy.  And mahalo for taking time to tune in and learn.

-Darla and Eric

Professional Profile: Emily Kelly

Another professional profile!

compiled by Eden Zang


1. Name.
Emily Kelly

2. Job Title.
PhD student at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography at the University of California, San Diego

3. Degree(s) held and from where.
I’m in the midst of my PhD now at Scripps / UCSD. I have an MS from the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor in Resource Ecology and Management where my research focused on how people of seemingly disparate interests can come to the table to make resource use decisions together. My BS is from Duke University in Durham, North Carolina.

4. Brief description of your job.
My job as a scientist is to ask questions and figure out experiments to answer those questions. What a cool job, huh?

5. Briefly describe the project(s) you are currently working on.
My dissertation research is focused at Kahekili Herbivore Fisheries Management Area. I’m interested in how the fish, urchins, coral, and algae all interact on the reef. Kahekili is the perfect place to investigate this because no herbivorous fish and urchins are allowed to be taken from the reef here. This is a new management strategy put into place by the Division of Aquatic Resources to see if increasing the number of herbivorous fish and urchins on the reef could decrease the amount of algae on the reef- an exciting and hopeful prospect as algae has been increasing on the reef and coral health has been declining over the past 15 years. My main projects right now are:

• Measuring algae growth and herbivore grazing on the reef
• Determining how much herbivore grazing is due to fish and how much is due to urchins
• Figuring out if fish and urchins like high nutrient algae (think: a breakfast of eggs and bacon) more than low nutrient algae (think: a breakfast of Twinkies)

6. Explain how/why your job is important to society.
My goal is to be able to help contribute to understanding how coral reefs work and thereby be able to help protect them and keep them healthy for the future. It’s very exciting to be able to do scientific research that has immediate implications for policy and management.

7. How did you end up doing what you’re doing?
My parents took my brother and me on lots of outdoor trips while were we growing up. When we were in the ocean, I always loved sticking my head underwater and watching what all the critters were up to. I’m fortunate to now be able to do that as my job!

8. Were you inspired by anyone in particular? If so, who, and how did he/she influence your career choice?
I had a lot of amazing teachers when growing up that encouraged me and the other students to work hard and pursue our interests. My high school chemistry and environmental science teacher, Mr. Shifrin, was one of those teachers who made science fun and inspired his students to think about how to tackle the challenges facing our planet. That enthusiasm and encouragement helped me realize that in addition to thinking science was cool, I could actually DO science if I wanted to.

9. What is the most rewarding aspect of your job?
The most rewarding aspect of my job is communicating the results of our work!

10. If you could change one aspect of your job, what would it be?
I wish equipment would move itself sometimes. Maybe SCUBA tanks could have little wings? And teleporting would be nice, too.

11. Describe the most fun and exciting experience you have had during your career.
Does hanging out with the frogfish on the reef count? I love that little (or not so little anymore) guy. Otherwise, I think the most fun experience is the whole experience of being in the water every day and really getting to know certain reefs really well.

12. Describe the most disappointing or frustrating experience you have had during your career.
---

13. What do you like to do on your days off?
Go for a hike on Haleakala! And eat banana cream pie from Auntie Lorraine’s 

14. What advice would you give to a student who is thinking about pursuing a career similar to yours?
Science is so fun!
Don’t be intimidated by math and science- just work hard and think of all the cool things you’ll be able to do with the knowledge you gain in those classes.
Be persistent in pursuing opportunities to work or meet with people who are doing things you think are cool.

15. Can you recommend any particular educational programs/internships, etc. that will help students prepare for a career like yours?
The easiest way to gain experience: Spend time outside observing. Look for patterns. Notice behaviors, timing, cycles, coincidences. Then think about why/how/where/what/when and see what you could do to test your ideas. That’s what science is all about!

If you’re in high school, visit the local college or university to see if there’s a lab you could volunteer in.

For college students looking for research experience, consider:

• NSF’s Research Experiences for Undergraduates Program 
• NOAA’s Hollings Scholarship Program

If you'd like to learn more about Emily and her work, visit her website!

Professional Profile: Scott Benson

compiled by Eden Zang

1. Name: Scott Benson

2. Job Title: Diver/Marine Biologist, Maui Ocean Center

3. Degree(s) held and from where.
    AA, Chabot College, Biology
    BA University of California, Santa Barbara, Aquatic Biology

4. Brief description of your job.
 Animal Husbandry for aquarium exhibits including marine fish and invertebrate acquisitions, collections, returns of animal to ocean, feeding, diets, population dynamics, disease treatments, exhibit maintenance, water flow dynamics, offshore pipe maintenance, equipment maintenance, "Shark Dive Maui" Dive Master.

5. Briefly describe the project(s) you are currently working on.
Acquisition of marine animals to permits issued by DLNR. Continuous improvements to existing exhibits, maintaining effluent water sampling techniques, improvements to fish and invertebrate diversity, release of 5 green sea turtles and entry of 6 new baby green sea turtles.

6. Explain how/why your job is important to society.
Public education for the marine sciences and husbandry. To understand the link of the Hawaiian culture, tradition, spiritual and balance (pono) the Hawaiian culture has had and still have with the oceans.

7. How did you end up doing what you’re doing?
Briefly, I was hired immediately out of school to be employed as an associate Marine Biologist with a consulting firm in Santa Barbara. We were contracted to do marine biological/oceanographic research for a nuclear power plant (Diablo Canyon baseline study), US wide drilling fluid discharge studies, coastal municipality waste water effluent studies. Oregon State marine science center Newport, cetacean research, northwest coastal informative center liaison for dissemination of current academic research to government, academic and private industries.


8. Were you inspired by anyone in particular? If so, who, and how did he/she influence your career choice?
When I was in 7th grade, I decided I wanted to be a marine biologist. I began diving at age 15. My father introduced me to Jacques Cousteau in 1971 as a Senior in High School at a Chancellor Change ceremony at U.C. Berkley. That was my catalyst. I had a mentor, Robert Meek, PhD. who guided me along this journey. My parents were responsible for creating the environment for me to excel in my dream!

9. What is the most rewarding aspect of your job?
Wow! The care and respect of our ocean creatures. To help people who don't fully understand, approach some understanding of just how fragile our planet is, covered by 3/4 oceans. To see the joy and amazement of their witness to such an incredible marine world. To work with so many dedicated individuals within our organization and external groups.

10. If you could change one aspect of your job, what would it be?
Increase public awareness of the depletion of ocean resources, sharks, dolphins, whales for consumption and trophy. We need to educate our young to step up and assume responsibility for education and ownership of our oceans for its protection period. We need to have legislation supporting these young care takers in their endeavors.

11. Describe the most fun and exciting experience you have had during your career.
More than one can imagine! I guess untangling an adult female grey whale from entangled line from a suspended 500lb crab pot off the coast of Newport, Oregon. I freed her after some effort and she was on her way north and caught up with her pod. Determine offshore drilling fluid discharge rate was acceptable concerning environmental impact. Knowing information I provided through the Northwest Coastal Information Center helped the entities I provided new research findings. So much more over a lifetime of experience.

12. Describe the most disappointing or frustrating experience you have had during your career.
I don't care how many degrees one has, but common sense takes precedence! Offshore experience with the activities associated during operations is critical. I told a PhD group of scientists that a diver buddy of mine was in danger. They did not listen. He almost lost his life. Human mistake took the life of two buddies in the North Sea. I almost lost my life 4 separate activities offshore. Do not ever take mother ocean for granted.

13. What do you like to do on your days off?
Play. I mean we are surrounded by so much adventure, hiking, diving, exploring, Hawaiian culture, traveling to visit family and friends, entertaining, movies, sitting at home reading fiction/fact, cooking, watching science channels of TV, listening to classic rock and classical music.

14. What advice would you give to a student who is thinking about pursuing a career similar to yours?
Develop a passion! If one has a passion, the rest will come. A young person will gather momentum from parents, siblings and friends. Get a sincere and dedicated education. The marine sciences cycles. We as the world is finally figuring out the oceans are very critical to our existence. Grab on to it and help pass the torch.

15. Can you recommend any particular educational programs/internships, etc. that will help students prepare for a career like yours?
Investigate all opportunities. Create a viable resume of your passion and pursue that entity fitting your interests. Do not take "no" as their first response. Be aggressive and go after what you want. As far as educational programs, obtain curriculum of any state or university that will accredit internship to your academic overall class credit program. Get involved with any activity pertaining to your major. Diving collections, offshore work, lab employment. Enthusiasm will take one a long way. Keep a mental picture of you goals strive to be the best at what you do. You may not be a millionaire but your heart and mind will be true!
Some advice from a person who has enjoyed a wonderful life experience sharing and protecting our oceans.
- Scott Benson

Scott with Eden Zang at the Maui Ocean Center's sea turtle release event on Ka'anapali Beach, August 2011

Check out the seat pocket in front of you next time you fly

by Emily Kelly

On my recent trip to Oahu for a Hawaii Coral Reef Initiative meeting, I picked up the Hawaiian Airlines magazine for some light reading. To my delight, there was a great article on the Reef Environmental Education Foundation (REEF), featuring Liz Foote! REEF is "a grass-roots organization that seeks to conserve marine ecosystems by educating, enlisting and enabling divers and other marine enthusiasts to become active ocean stewards and citizen scientists." Regarding collecting data on Maui's reefs, the magazine quoted Liz as saying, "You don't need a PhD to make important observations and contribute relevant data." TOTALLY! Thanks for the in-flight inspiration, Liz, and let's all get out there and participate!

Professional Profile: Pauline Fiene

By Eden Zang

Project S.E.A.-Link, a nonprofit organization based on Maui, has approached several individuals who are dedicated to marine science, education, conservation and sustainable tourism to share their experiences with students and the general community as part of its Professional Profiles project for this site.

The first professional we profiled is Pauline Fiene, a divemaster at Mike Severns Diving and biologist on Maui. She guides other divers and helps them to learn about and appreciate the underwater environment and the lives of the animals that they see. As a biologist she also makes observations and studies marine subjects both while leading dives and during dives that she makes on her own.

One of her main interests is studying subjects over a long period of time in their natural habitat. Along with Cory Pittman, she has studied Hawaiian opisthobranchs for over 20 years.

Phyllidia varicosa, photo by Pauline Fiene

 

One particular project she is most known for is the study of the spawning pattern of two species of corals which spawn mainly in the spring. Opportunities for observation are limited to a few times each year and because of that, it has taken many years to learn their spawning patterns.

She is also passionate about learning about individual animals' lives. Being in the water and working with crew who care and share their observations, allows learning about an animal's life history or behavior in the wild as no other method can. For example, long-term observations of a triton's trumpet with its eggs over a six-week period and of a sponge with five resident nudibranchs for over four years are recent examples of such long-term study.

Pauline is obviously passionate about her career. Pauline states, "Sharing knowledge and the underwater experience with other people opens their eyes to things they might not ever have known without your influence. That's important to that individual, but you just don't know what larger influence that may have." When asked if Pauline could change anything about her job she simply stated "sea conditions." Wouldn't that be great?

So would you like a career like Pauline's? Fiene states, "It's all about the passion. If you have that you will find your path. If you have a passion for something, you don't wait for a grant. You begin to do it on your own time if that's what it takes. If being outdoors is a critical element when you think about what you want to do for a living, this is ideal, because it's both physical and it stimulates your mind. I can't think of anything more rewarding than working outdoors with animals and combining that with intellectual pursuits."

If you'd like to find out more about Pauline Fiene, please visit the following links:

Mike Severns Diving

Sea Slugs of Hawaii

If you have questions for Pauline, please contact us and we will relay your question.

Interested in being profiled or know someone who might? Contact us! 

Kaanapali Makai Watch Coordinator Luna Kekoa's Report on the KHFMA Birthday Bash

by Luna Kekoa

On a sun shining , windy July 23^rd, the Kahekili Herbivore Fisheries Management area celebrated its second year of existence with a Birthday Bash!  This event was hosted by the Kaanapali Makai Watch team, as well as the NOAA Humpack Whale Sanctuary and Marine Mammal Stranding team, and the West Maui Watershed partnership. 

Honorary guests to the KHFMA celebration included our Maui County Council members Mike Victorino, Joe Pontanilla, and Elle Cochran who shared their perspectives and concerns of the area with community members and volunteers.
 

As part of the celebration the community was encouraged to participate with an underwater scavenger hunt, and for those who couldn’t get wet, there was also a land-based scavenger hunt.  One group of volunteers participated in a Fish Identification Network (FIN) fish count survey,  while another group conducted water quality samples.  On land, beach-goer surveys and herbivore identification surveys were being conducted with park visitors and hotel guests.  Once the surveys were completed the group gathered around for some cake.  This year, researchers conducting experiments in the Kahekili area created KHFMA theme cakes that included a manini(convict tang) cake, a coral cake (with healthy and unhealthy reef), and urchin cupcakes. 

We would like to mahalo all participants who visited and shared in the KHFMA Birthday Bash!

Kahekili, a "Hope Spot" for Hawaii, celebrates its 2nd birthday!

by Coral Rick

Early on a Saturday morning a Medieval village of tents began to grow on the shore of North Ka`anapali.  Slowly the tents were erected one by one by a small clan of Menehunue (disguised as Makai Watch) so that government and NGO folks could set up their exhibits. The posters were hung, the colorful pamphlets were laid out on the tables, and the freshly prepared foods were arranged in a tempting spread. And the pilgrims arrived from far and wide with flippers and snorkels and BCDS and wetsuits and heavy cans of air. And they brought their children - the future scientists and leaders. They came for many reasons: some to enjoy the sun and surf; others to count fish; and all came to celebrate the second anniversary of a marine protected area called the Kahekili Herbivore Fisheries Management Area.

Armed only with underwater slates and cameras, a dozen snorkelers slipped into the ocean further up the beach, allowing the constant wind to help them drift South and back to the village of tents.  Then smaller groups of divers turned on the valves of their air tanks and kicked slowly offshore before drifting down to the reef below. All were greeted by hungry schools of fish – herbivores – parrotfish and surgeonfish chomping away and keeping the coral reef from being overwhelmed by the algae.  In a soundless exchange of solidarity, a dozen divers waved and gave the “okay” sign to a dozen snorkelers patrolling from the surface.  They had come to see the abundance of marine life and they found biodiversity.  Scattered across the bottom of the reef were the experiments of scientists in big metal cages (under permit, of course) studying the role of urchins in the health of the coral reef ecosystem.

Back on shore, with gear cleaned up and packed away, they feasted and posed for photographs. Of course there was a Kahekili birthday cake.  And, of course there was the traditional group photo with everyone wearing funny little birthday hats.  Sylvia Earle has a dream of “hope spots” – places that are critical to the health of the ocean.  Kahekili is a “hope spot” in the main Hawaiian Islands because it was doomed to become another reef collapse.  But, thanks to the work of scientists, government, community and volunteers, there is hope.

P.S.  Two more exciting fish counts are being planned for August and September, so follow us on Facebook

To see more photos from the event, visit the Ka'anapali Makai Watch page on facebook!

Update from Hawaii Coastal Zone Management & NOAA on the West Maui Watershed Collaborative Planning Project

At the Coastal Zone 2011 (CZ11) Conference in Chicago on July 20, 2011, a special session was held on the US Coral Reef Task Force priority partnership initiatives called “Managing Coral Reefs from Ridge to Reef – Working in Partnership across Federal and State Agencies and Non-governmental Organizations to Address Local Needs.”  The two priority partnerships are West Maui Watershed/ Kaanapali Hawaii Coral Reef Strategy Priority Site for the Pacific and Guanica Bay, Puerto Rico for the Caribbean.
Visit this link to see the presentation given at CZ11 for West Maui which provides a good update and overview of the actions and strategy for collaboration.

DOCARE's Observation & Incident Reporting workshop for Makai Watch

by Luna Kekoa 

On June 23^rd the Kaanapali Makai Watch hosted a DOCARE community training at the Kaunoa Center in Lahaina, Maui.  This was the first, in a statewide series, of community meetings to inform the public, community, and Makai Watch volunteers, as to the role of DOCARE in the Makai Watch program.  This was also an opportunity for DOCARE and the community to interact and express concerns about the reporting process and follow up from DOCARE.   

With more than 30 in attendance the meeting brought both rookie and veteran Makai Watch volunteers from West, Central, and South Maui.  There were 8 DOCARE officers that participated in the meeting including the head of DOCARE Randy Awo.  Brooks Tamaye and Matt Yamamoto took the lead for DOCARE and led the audience through a presentation that explained the roles and responsibilities of DOCARE officers.  The presentation included the reporting process for violations and the follow up that occurs with DOCARE.    

Next, the community participated in an exercise consisting of examining pictures to point out both violations and common mistakes with reporting violations, such as not understanding gear restrictions or site specific regulations.  DOCARE ended the evening with displaying confiscated gear that were illegal to allow the community the ability to examine and see first hand what “illegal” fishing gear looks like.

The next step for the Kaanapali Makai Watch is to hold a site specific community meeting to discuss specific site regulations of the Kahekili Herbivore Fisheries Management Area. The meeting is being planned for early October. The statewide series of meetings has completed the second community meeting in Waikiki, Oahu.  There will be more meetings being held on neighboring islands coming soon as well!

To see more photos from the event, check out the facebook album!

A Fisherman's Perspective

by Eden Zang

“Fishermen are conservationists. We want management. Status quo is killing our reef.” - Darrell Tanaka

Darrell Tanaka, local fisherman and the organizer of Roi Roundup, spoke Thursday, June 9th at the Hawaiian Islands Humpback Whale National Marine Sanctuary’s volunteer meeting. Tanaka spoke about the origins of the Roi Roundup, an “invasive species spearfishing tournament,” and why continued efforts are imperative. The roi roundup started as a fundraising effort and has morphed into a conservation movement. It brings together fishermen, local government and scientists to address the impact of roi on our local marine ecosystem and to address our ailing resources. Roi, or the peacock grouper, is an alien species introduced in the 1950’s to Hawaiian waters. Darrell made reference to research by University of Hawaii researcher Dr. Jan Dierking, which demonstrates that roi consume local reef fish, finding that a single roi can consume approximately 146 reef fish a year. Multiply that by the hundreds of thousands of roi currently in our waters and it may represent a significant threat to our fisheries. In addition, they can potentially outcompete our local fish for the food they would normally eat.

Tanaka made it clear that he was sharing his own opinions in his presentation, and has a degree in marine biology in addition to being a life-long fisherman. Tanaka made quite clear he fishes not for sport, but to put food on the table. He explained that fish is a resource and not a commodity for him. The difference? A commodity is something you can sell or trade. A resource is something that has great value and is kept for yourself or given to someone extremely important to you.

Tanaka spoke from a fisherman’s point of view. He fielded questions from the crowd and encouraged tough questions. It was a raw perspective and as Tanaka said several times he’s not “sugar coating” anything and instead wanted to present the “grim reality.” From “Marine Protected Areas” vs. “Fisheries Management Areas,” monk seals, turtles, local management strategies here on Maui and statewide, recreational fishing licenses and so forth...Tanaka answered all questions that came his way.

Video of the presentation can be found on Hawaii EcoTube's YouTube Channel Playlist - "What Folks are Saying."

Conservation can be a sensitive subject. Pointing fingers gets us nowhere. We all have to work for the good of the reef, Tanaka emphasized. One way to protect our oceans is having the right resource enforcement numbers on hand at all times. 

Program these two numbers in your phone RIGHT NOW: DOCARE & the police non-emergency police line for Maui:

Maui DOCARE office: (808) 873- 3990

Maui Police non-emergency line: (808) 244-6400

Grab the Division of Aquatic Resources’ fishing regulations booklet (available at all DAR offices and online at the DAR website) and learn the rules. Download the “Making a Difference Action Guide”  which provides guidelines on how to respond to various issues including fishing violations, and has a chart listing the DOCARE, DAR & police nonemergency numbers for each island, among many other things.

If you report a suspected illegal fishing method make sure you have all the correct information. Report what exactly someone is doing illegally. Also, get a description of the car make, model, license plate and description of the people.

Darrell encouraged people to attend the upcoming workshop in Lahaina on June 23^rd (5:30 -7:30 pm at the Kaunoa West Maui Senior Center) sponsored by DOCARE and Makai Watch partners.

Facebook event listing

Maui News notice

Tanaka and fellow fishermen found a way to utilize their passion and skills to give back to the community. What a great example for us all to do our part no matter how big or small!

 ***

A few references to explore:

“The impact of invasive roi on Hawaii's native reef fishes” YouTube video segment from Outside Hawaii, featuring Dr. John Randall

“Scientists probe impacts of invasive roi on local fish” - article by Scott Radway, in the Hawaii Fisheries Local Action Strategy

Feeding biology of the introduced fish roi (Cephalopholis argus) in Hawaii, and its impact on Hawaiian coral reef fishes and fisheries. NOAA Final Project Report (Jan 31 2005)

Dr. Jan Dierking’s thesis publication

The Future of Honu Management

There is a lot of buzz going around about an upcoming meeting on Oahu, a Fishers Forum on "The Future of Honu Management" which is part of a larger meeting of the Western Pacific Regional Fishery Management Council.

Here is the flier and a link to it online:

One can imagine there will be a variety of perspectives surrounding this issue. Here is one, and we'd like to invite others via the comment section.

The following is from the email listserv CTURTLE* by Peter Bennett (author of numerous books and publications on turtles and the website Turtle Trax, www.turtles.org), and is posted here with his permission:

Date: Tue, 07 Jun 2011 14:54:32 -0400
From: Peter Bennett <honu@turtles.org>

I'm copying this to everyone who has written us in the past few days about this issue, or has been copied in correspondence.

Sylvia [WPRFMC] did ask permission to use our images. Under our copyright policy, she didn't have to and we appreciated the courtesy. We reserve the right to disallow usage that we feel is detrimental to the honu, but we don't believe that this qualifies.

I disagree that the poster supports hunting. It does leave no doubt that harvesting will be considered as an option, but that is not support.

There is no question that the recovery of the honu has been a spectacular success. They have become so plentiful that, regardless of the truth, it is easy to see why people conclude that some reefs have reached carrying capacity.

In our area [West Maui] the honu have begun feeding throughout the day. We count fewer honu resting on the reef, and our snorkel/dive surveys have found that the foragers are competing for a diminishing supply of food. It is tempting to reason that this is happening throughout the Islands, thus explaining at least in part the increase of reports of daytime foraging along the shorelines.

Discussion of a harvest is therefore inevitable. Even those opposed to a cull should support a forum such as this one. If there are solid reasons why a hunt should not be approved, then there shouldn't be fear of an open and honest debate. WesPac is providing an opportunity to put forward and explain these reasons. In fact, opponents of hunt should welcome the chance to demonstrate why such a thing is unacceptable.

Our own philosophy on this matter--which sometimes surprises people--is expressed in The Book of Honu (p. 125):

Our affection for the honu means that of course we don't want to see them hunted. If, however, their numbers have recovered to the point where a regulated harvest would not threaten the overall population, then we find it hard to oppose. Our objections would be strictly emotional, not scientific. We'd insist that such a hunt be strictly controlled and that safeguards be put in place to prevent hunting in areas where human contact has acclimated the turtles. If these conditions met, we wouldn't like the idea, but we'd be forced to accept it.

Thanks to all of you who thought our opinion was important enough to bring this to our attention.

Thoughts? Post them in the comments.


* interested in subscribing to the CTURTLE listserv?

Please follow these steps to subscribe to CTURTLE:

1) Send an email message to LISTSERV@lists.ufl.edu with the one-line message
SUBSCRIBE CTURTLE (your first name) (your last name)

2) To post information to all subscribers on the list, send an email message to CTURTLE@lists.ufl.edu

3) To get general information on LISTSERV commands, send an email message to LISTSERV@lists.ufl.edu with the one-line message
GET LISTSERV REFCARD

If you want further information you can go to the CTURTLE website

Kids color herbivores for World Oceans Day!

We were at the Maui Ocean Center yesterday for the World Oceans Day celebration along with many other local NGOs and agencies, and had the coloring pages on hand for the Herbivore Coloring Contest. By a wonderful coincidence our table was situated right in front of the Surgeonfishes exhibit, which gave us the opportunity to show kids the actual fishes they were coloring and teach about them. Kids then posed with their drawings AND the fishes (after getting parental permission of course).

Check out the full album of photos of kids and their artwork!

Thanks to the Maui Ocean Center for hosting the event, and to Monika Mira for putting together the contest in support of the Kahekili Herbivore Fisheries Management Area and the Kaanapali Makai Watch program!

Happy World Oceans Day!

Aloha, friends of Kahekili!

We hope you had a great World Oceans Day! Clinton Edwards (left) and I celebrated with our first dive back on the reef for our summer field season. Enjoying the beauty and diversity of our reef and following around a school of herbivores is a great way to celebrate the oceans, huh? We hope your celebration was just as fun and hope you did some great coloring, too. Clint and I will be working on experiments out on the reef over the next few months, along with Levi Lewis, Jackie Tran, and others. We'll continue our on-going work on herbivores and algae inside KHFMA and look forward to updating you on what experiments are in the water through Maui Ocean Bloggers.

And since celebrating and honoring our oceans doesn't have to be limited to June 8 every year, let's get back in the water!

Help us design the KHFMA T-shirt!

First of all, thanks to everyone who has contributed their help with our various outreach efforts and products! We have found that by using social media, we can get a great dialog going and involve many people with great ideas!

Darla White is now spearheading the development of a new t-shirt design utilizing the artistic talents of Jonatha Giddens to convey a key ecological concept - the importance of herbivory. The draft design is below, and the purpose is to demonstrate that healthy populations of herbivores promote healthy reefs. A reef with more herbivores, and LARGER herbivores (because of their disproportionate reproductive & grazing capacity) will be better off than a reef with depleted stocks of herbivores. Lose the herbivores, and the reef could degrade in the face of multiple stressors, particular algal overgrowth and invasive algae.
That is the "big picture" message, so we'd like your help in coming up with some text that effectively conveys that concept.

On a t-shirt.

So it needs to be as brief & concise as possible!

Have at it, and leave your suggestions in the comments here, or on Kaanapali Makai Watch's Facebook Page.

posted by Liz.